Interest

South Africa's insurance gap is not a product problem

5 min readCPS

R50.4 trillion. That’s the size of South Africa’s life and disability insurance shortfall at the end of 2024, according to ASISA’s latest Insurance Gap Study, up from R35.4 trillion three years before. Roughly seven times the size of the whole economy. The average earner needs about R2.1 million of death cover and has R0.8 million. Disability cover is worse, if you can believe that.

So what does the industry usually do with a number like that? Cheaper products. Simpler wording. Wider distribution. None of it’s wrong, but it all assumes the gap is really a sales and pricing problem. It mostly isn’t. Most of the people doing the selling were trained to explain a policy, not to work out what the person in front of them actually needs protecting against.

That’s the whole problem, really, tucked inside what sounds like a small distinction.

Why product knowledge only gets you so far

Spend a day inside most product training and you’ll come out knowing policy features, premium structures, how your plan stacks up against the one down the road. Fine, useful stuff. What it won’t teach anyone is how to sit across from a client and work out what that specific household is actually exposed to. What happens to them if the breadwinner dies next year. Whether the cover they’ve already got would survive eighteen months off work with a disability. What gets cut, and by how much, if the income just stops.

That’s an advisory conversation. Not a sales one. It asks something different of whoever’s sitting in that chair.

Only around 6 percent of South Africans are thought to be on track for a comfortable retirement, and the country’s financial literacy numbers aren’t much better. Sit that next to a R50 trillion gap and you start to see the actual shape of the problem. People aren’t short on products to choose from. They’re short on someone who can take their messy, specific life and turn it into a coverage decision they understand well enough to actually trust.

What gets missed when training stops at the product

Insurers that lean entirely on product certification keep hitting the same wall. Advisor turnover climbs. Conversion swings wildly, client to client. Policies lapse within a year or two, about the worst outcome going for the client and whoever sold the cover. Meanwhile the regulatory ground keeps moving under all of it, with the FSCA’s Fit and Proper requirements pushing the minimum bar higher. Product-only training was never built to clear that bar. Honestly, it was built to move stock.

Strip it back and this was never really a sales problem. It just wears one as a disguise. Underneath, it’s a capability gap, and it’s not that far removed from something CPS kept circling at its Future Skills Forum in October: having access to information, or to a wide shelf of products, isn’t the same thing as knowing what to do with either. An advisor who knows the products but not the person will close a few deals and lose most of the relationships that would’ve actually mattered. And relationships are the business here, not the sale. A claim lands years after the paperwork’s signed. A renewal comes round every single year, for decades. People’s lives change, more than once, and the advice has to keep pace.

A commission-based insurance career already takes something like 70 percent longer to build into something stable than a salaried role does elsewhere in financial services. Try doing that on product knowledge alone and you’ll start to see why so many good people wash out before year one is even up, leaving a book of business that never got the chance to grow into anything. The ones who stick around tend to be the ones who were handed a real professional foundation early, not just a script and a monthly number to hit. Somewhere along the way, they worked out the job was advisory work wearing a commission structure as a disguise, not the other way round.

The advisory gap hiding underneath the protection gap

Here’s the part worth sitting with. The products exist, plenty of them. The distribution exists too, probably more of it than there’s ever been, banks, brokers, direct platforms, workplace schemes. What’s missing, at scale, is a workforce big enough to have the right conversation with the right person at the right moment in their life. Not a pitch. An honest read of someone’s actual risk, handed back to them in language they can do something with.

This is roughly the gap CPS had in mind when it built the Long Term Insurance Advisor qualification, an NQF 5 programme, QCTO-registered and developed with INSETA, built around risk assessment, ethical practice and client relationship management rather than product memorisation.

What trusted advisor actually means

A trusted advisor gets used so often in marketing copy that it’s basically stopped meaning anything. Strip the branding off and it comes down to something fairly ordinary: a client who believes their advisor is thinking about their protection, not their commission, at the moment it actually counts. That belief doesn’t come from a firm handshake or a nice app. It comes from competence a client can feel, even when they couldn’t put a name to it. The right question at the right time. A recommendation that clearly fits their actual life, not something pulled off a shelf because it was closest to hand.

Building that kind of competence on purpose costs more up front than product training ever will. It costs far less than what the alternative produces: advisors burning out inside two years, clients who felt sold to rather than looked after, a protection gap that keeps growing no matter how many fresh products hit the shelves. Picture the client who gets a call eight months after buying a policy, not to upsell them, but because their advisor remembered something mentioned once, almost in passing, about a change coming in their life. That call is what advisory capability actually looks like. Nobody puts it in a brochure. It’s still exactly what keeps a book of business alive for decades instead of months.

Nobody in this industry owes anyone an apology for selling insurance. People need cover, and selling it properly is honest work. But the conversation worth having inside most insurers and brokerages right now probably isn’t about the next product launch at all. It’s whether the people sitting across from clients are actually equipped for that conversation, and what it would take to get them there.

We use cookies to measure site usage and improve your experience. Decline to opt out at any time. See our Privacy Policy for details.